Tuesday, April 24, 2012

The rise of the adonis complex response by Melissa Monsalve

For the most part, most people would not expect men to feel pressured by society anywhere near as much as women are. However, as this article shows, all things considered, men are just as pressured to look a certain way just as much as women are. The difference is that on top of the pressure, men are also told to keep their emotions that may show weakness bottled up. This has caused the general public to remain out of the loop with the self-esteem/self-imaging issues affects boys and men of any age. It really should come as no surprise that men are also pressured. Images of these huge, bulky muscled men that look as if that had been created by CGI or the marketing of male action figures who's proportions in real life would be impossible to achieve created an illusion of an "ideal" male body image. When a skinny, lanky guy or a short, chubby guy has grown up accepting these images as the ideal, how could they not feel insecure about themselves? Although I won't lie that I was surprised at the rate at which men are receiving plastic surgery or have eating disorders, it would only make sense. Men are not "allowed" to express their insecurities, so they take more silent routes to achieve their goal: surgery or eating disorders. Because men are not expected to go to such lengths to achieve such a goal, they can probably play it of somehow without being questioned or doubted as much as a woman would be. Another pressure comes from gender supriority. Being the dominate gender is both a blessing and a curse for men. In some aspects they may receive more privileges than women, but they are also subject to a great amount of ridiculous because they are seen as the better gender. This probably explains why in the article it states that men feel more pressured to look good for the opposite sex. They may feel that women as the subservient gender can ridicule and judge their bodies. This pressure is also do to the fact that men find some sort of worth in how attractive they are seen by the opposite sex because that then gains validation as a man from his male friends, which is a topic we explored in class earlier in the semester. The reality of the situation with men an their body images has been distorted, making it seem like its only women who worry about their looks. So what do we to help these boys and men? It's difficult to say. Because men are even under more pressure than women are to express their sexuality (because being anything but a heterosexual man is seen as wrong by most of society) men can't express their insecurities or come out and say that they have an eating disorder or that they have received plastic surgery, thus making it difficult to change this tide of negative male body image. This article just goes to show that men are in just as much of a pickle as women are in terms of pressures for an "ideal" body image.

5 comments:

  1. Melissa- You do a great job in the beginning of your response in bringing up the fact that men are almost equally as concerned with their appearance as women are, yet the public does not necessarily perceive this the same way. I think you really hit the nail on the head when you say that men are supposed to keep their emotions and weaknesses bottled up because a "real man" would never show he is vulnerable. I couldn't help but think if a man were to get emotional about his body or figure, would society perceive him as gay or feminine? I also like how you brought up the point that society has kind of made plastic surgery a thing that only women do, yet in the article we see that men often resort to plastic surgery, or even worse, have eating disorders. Good Job!- Keith Veronesi

    ReplyDelete
  2. Women are very openly expected to have nice and lean bodies. Media portrays women's bodies open for gazing and constant critique. I think this is why women's appearance and bodies are much more talked about. For example, there is a scene in Mean Girls where three of the girls stand in front of a mirror and point out each of their flaws. After listing their flaws, they look to the new girl, Cadi and wait for her to critique herself, because, apparently, no girl should be completely happy with their body. She kind of panics, not sure how to put herself and appearance down and says, "Ummm well, my breath smells bad when I wake up". Throughout the movie, she slowly becomes obsessed with her appearance. Women is media are already portrayed as vulnerable. You are right on in your post when you say that because men are portrayed as emotionless, strong, and dominant, it would be "unmanly" for them to show vulnerability.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Melissa makes a good point that society does not expect a man to feel the same pressure regarding appearance as a female. However this article refutes such a belief and proves that the same pressure that leads females to bodily extremes exist for men. I agree that because men are not supposed to be emotional or show any sign of weakness their struggles are more invisible. Men are just as vulnerable to social pressure as females but because of their “masculine nature” their vulnerability is forgotten and ignored. Men are supposed to be dominate to women and this leads to an idea that their bodies must be bigger, stronger, and better, than those around them. I agree that a man’s dominant nature is both pushing them towards extremes but also to blame for the little support they receive.

    ReplyDelete
  4. It's true that society that does not have the same expectations for men as they do for women. Men are expected to work out and be the tough manly man and of course women are not. However women are meant to be fit and have this amazing body that they may not have. Women are also more open about their bodies. When women don't like something about their bodies they will say it but men are expected to keep their emotions on lock down. Men do have struggles just like women and both men and women's struggles should be seen but this is not the case. However because men aren't expected to be emotional they can control their emotions better than women so they may not need to stress how they feel as much as a women does.

    Jae

    ReplyDelete
  5. Well done, Melissa. I think you touched upon the crux of the article in discussing that "men are not "allowed" to express their insecurities." This double standard is clear in the article, and it is a fascinating one at that, because as we see the pressures placed on boys to bulk up and exert their masculinity, with pressure only comes stress and heightened emotion, and, as you said, there is no place for that in mainstream culture. The ideal of a man is so skewed by television, film, and music, but the process of achieving that goal should be effortless and 'no big deal' for a man. On the other hand, losing weight and improving one's physical appearance seems to be a inherent part of a woman's life, and she can express her insecurities however she likes, even in front of other men. But boys are forbidden, essentially, to discuss any insecurities. This seems like cruelty on society's part!

    ReplyDelete