Saturday, February 11, 2012

"Tough Guise" Response- Ellie Merrell


“Tough Guise”, a film about the front that men put up in order to appear masculine, greatly disturbed me. Although it reiterated many of the concepts already addressed in “Bros before Hos”, the images that accompanied the facts really drove home notions about how society expects its boys and men to behave and how boys and men respond to those expectations. The film initially addressed the role that the media plays in teaching guys masculinity. Particularly in movies like “Rambo” or shows about professional fighters, the film argues that dominance, power, and control are depicted as ideals for which men should strive. With most guys striving to dominate, overpower, or control each other, it is amazing to me that men enjoy the company of their same-sex friends. Always feeling like my friends were trying to undermine me or were waiting to call me out when I slip up would give me a great deal of anxiety.
The media also has a tendency to represent violence as a norm for men, a tendency which appears to have an effect on the rate of violent crimes perpetrated by males as opposed to females. When all of these messages about what constitutes masculinity are added together, a really concerning combination is created. We end up with men who are striving for impossible ideals and who, when they fail to attain those ideals, will only have violence as an outlet for their frustration. Not good.
            A concept developed in “Tough Guise” that I found particularly interesting is the idea that the gay and women’s movements affected men’s identities and perceptions of masculinity. It’s odd to think how, as these two groups gained flexibility and liberty, men’s capability to step out of the masculinity box and experiment with different ideas about what constitutes manhood diminished. It was striking to see how the country’s perceptions and the media’s representations of manly-men have changed over the course of history in response to events like equality movements.

No comments:

Post a Comment